Update (2/25/10)–Mass. High Court May Take Ibanez Case
I’ve been asked several times recently for an update on the status of Land Court judge Keith Long’s controversial ruling in U.S. Bank v. Ibanez, which invalidated thousands of foreclosures across Massachusetts. Click here for my prior post on the case.
Unfortunately for those affected by the decision, not much is going on. Lenders have reportedly appealed the decision. Word has it that the lenders have hired mega-firm K&L Gates to handle the appeal. (Interestingly, K&L Gates is the same firm which secured a major ruling against the Massachusetts Real Estate Bar Association over non-attorneys handling real estate closings in Massachusetts).
The record in the Land Court is currently being assembled. The Massachusetts Appellate Court database doesn’t even list the case as yet up on appeal. Accordingly, this appeal is many, many months away from being decided.
Also, watch for the lenders to ask the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court to take the case on direct appeal. While this will delay the appeal some in the short term, the SJC is the final stop on the appellate railway, and its decision is the final word on the matter. Given the pro-consumer decisions recently issued by the high court and its current makeup of somewhat liberal justices, my money is still on an unfavorable decision for lenders in this case.
In the meantime, I’m hearing that lenders are simply re-doing their foreclosures with the correct loan paperwork (i.e., the mortgage assignments) brought up to date. For buyers who had an agreement to purchase a foreclosed home, this most likely means you will have to wait in line again and re-bid on the second foreclosure.
Subscribe By Email To This Blog!
{ 2 trackbacks }
{ 1 comment… read it below or add one }
I purchase a home prior to the judges decision. A year later I was at the closing table to sell my property when I was notified by the banks closing attorney that my property had defective title insurance due to the judge’s decision. The potential buyer got scared and walked away from the table. I then put in a claim with my title ins. co. That was 20 months ago. The title co. says they will not reimburse me for my losses. Instead they are in attempted litigation with the trustee of the owner before me. Yesterday I received a letter that the lawyer representing the title co. is offering 8000 dollars to the trustee to correct the problem. I just want to be clear of this property, because I know live in Germany.